How to Safely and Securely Sell Your Engagement Ring Online (And Get the Best Offer)

How to Safely and Securely Sell Your Engagement Ring Online (And Get the Best Offer)


Are you going through a difficult time and need to sell your engagement ring? Or simply want to release funds from a valuable asset?  We’re here for you. 

Whether you’re concerned about getting the best price, selling your ring to a trusted buyer, the emotional attachment of the ring, or the overall value of your ring, White Pine is here to walk you through every step of the process. And show how easy it can be to sell your engagement ring online. That’s why we wrote this blog. 

To help people like you safely and securely navigate the process of selling your engagement with confidence, so you can move forward with peace of mind and the best possible outcome.

In this post, we’ll take you through the entire process so you can make the most informed decision and get the best offer for your engagement ring. 

Let’s get started. 

(Note: If you’re ready to part with your engagement ring ASAP, head over to this page, fill out the short form, and we’ll be in touch within 24 hours.)


Selling Your Engagement Ring: Where to Start

There are usually a lot of questions people have when they begin their engagement ring-selling journey, so if you feel overwhelmed, know you’re not alone. 

We’ll break it down so the whole process is super simple. And then go into more detail later in this post.

The first step in selling your engagement ring is understanding that engagement rings (barring any extensive damage) do have resale value. Instead of asking yourself “Can I sell my engagement ring?”, a better first question is “What is the value of my engagement ring?”.

This brings us to step 2 – determining a ballpark range of what your ring is worth. 

To do this, you can either do your own research, or take it to a trusted diamond jewelry buyer and see what they say. There are a few different types of buyers you can take your engagement ring to, and we’ll review all of your options later on. 

Once you find a trusted buyer, the next step is to prepare your ring for sale. 

This can be an important step because it will help your ring look more appealing to potential buyers and could help you get a better price. 

Then comes the offer. You’ll receive the price with the buyer, complete any necessary paperwork, and finalize the sale. 

And that’s it – that’s the “sell engagement ring” process from start to finish, simplified. 

Next, we’ll dive into each part of the process in detail, providing you with tips and best practices during each phase. 



Determining the Value of Your Engagement Ring

Understanding the value of your engagement ring is crucial because it ensures you’ll get a fair price and avoid underselling it. 

Some people have the misconception that engagement rings don’t have resale value, but that’s not the case. Engagement rings, like most fine estate jewelry, hold value over time and can be resold to buyers. 

To determine the value of your engagement ring, you’ll want to look at factors like the quality of the diamond, the metal of the band, and the overall condition of the ring. 

If you’re not a diamond expert, the easier solution is to take it to a truster diamond jewelry buyer. They’ll have the knowledge and expertise to properly appraise your ring and give you an accurate quote. 

Which brings us to the next step in the process. 


Where to Sell Your Engagement Ring

Where you choose to sell your engagement ring is hands down the most important step in the process because it can determine the price you'll get for your ring and the level of security and trust you'll have in the transaction.

Sell it to the wrong buyer and you’ll risk getting a low price or being scammed.  Here are some of the different options for where you can sell your engagement ring:


Specialized Online Buyers

Specialized online buyers, such as White Pine, are often the safest and most secure way to sell your engagement ring, with fair and accurate valuations, discreet (and fast) transactions, and customer protection policies in place.

While it’s totally reasonable to be a little hesitant in putting your complete trust in someone you can’t physically see, specialized diamond estate jewelry buyers – at least the credible ones – will have a large catalog of customer testimonials and social proof that display their reputation for fair and honest transactions, providing you with peace of mind and assurance that you’ll get a fair deal for your ring.  


Jewelry Stores

Selling your engagement ring to a jewelry store can give you a fair and accurate valuation, but it's important to shop around for the best offer and know the market value of your ring.

While jewelry stores are generally a great option, they often only have a handle on local pricing and only buy stones that suit the local market (since that’s who they’re reselling to). Which means you could missing out on better prices with a national buyer.


Online Marketplaces

Online Marketplaces such as eBay, Craigslist, and Facebook Marketplace can be a quick and easy way to sell your engagement ring, but they also come with risks such as fraud and lack of protection. 

Definitely to do your research and read reviews before using these platforms.



Consignment is when you (the consignor), allow a retailer (the consignee) to sell your engagement ring for you. Which can allow you to get an offer without doing much (if any) work.

A common downside to consignment, however, is that the process is often slow. And when you do receive an offer for your ring, you then have to pay a percentage/commission back to the retailer, resulting in less take-home cash for you.


Auction Houses

Auction houses can be a good option for selling high-end engagement rings, but it requires a lot of research and knowledge of the market.

You’ll often run into commission fees, a long process, and a lot of bargaining with auction houses. 


Pawn Shops

Selling your engagement ring to a pawn shop can be a quick and easy way to get cash for your ring, but it's important to be aware that pawn shops typically offer lower prices than other options. 

Pawn shops may also want to keep the ring as collateral and loan you money against the ring. It's important to be aware of all the terms of the loan and the interest rate before engaging in such a transaction.


Red Flags to Watch For 

To help you eliminate diamond buyers that just want your ring and don’t have your best interest at heart, there are some specific red flags to watch out for. These include: 


Pressure to sell 

The buyer pressures you to sell your ring quickly or to accept a lower price.


Lack of transparency

The buyer isn’t upfront about their process, fees, or pricing.


Lowball offers

The buyer offers you a price that’s significantly lower than what you believe your ring is worth.

Note: It’s important to understand that your offer will not be the same as an insurance appraisal, which is inflated to cover the insurance practice of offering only part of the value as a replacement.


No certifications or licenses

The buyer doesn’t have any certifications or grade to the standards of professional organizations such as the Gemological Institute of America (GIA) or the American Gem Society (AGS).


No customer reviews or testimonials 

The buyer doesn’t have customer reviews or testimonials available to show their reputation and track record.


No customer protection policies

The buyer doesn’t have any customer protection policies in place or doesn’t offer free, insured returns if you don’t accept the offer. Above all, it’s important to do your own research. And as you can see, there are a lot of things to take into consideration when it comes to where to sell your engagement ring. Luckily for you, you’re already in the right place. 



Why White Pine is the Best Place to Sell Your Engagement Ring

You’ve not only landed on the most informative blog about how to sell your engagement ring, but you’ve also entered the virtual storefront of one of the leading diamond jewelry buyers –  White Pine. 

It’s a no-brainer if you want to work with a trusted and reputable buyer that’s been recognized as an industry leader for over a decade. Let’s show you around.



Since our inception in 2010, our aim has been to revolutionize the jewelry industry by utilizing natural recycled diamonds, championing its expansion. And we’ve done just that. 

Not only has there been an increase in the number of businesses that recognize the value and sustainability of recycled diamonds and the positive effects they have on the environment, but consumers are also becoming aware of the benefits of recycled diamonds. 

In addition to our diamond jewelry buying and selling services, we also provide diamond recutting, diamond sorting, CAD & custom work, jewelry setting, special orders, and diamond testing. 

When it comes to your engagement ring, you’re in good hands. Because we’ve purchased thousands of them over the years, and know what it takes to deliver a good customer experience and a competitive offer. 


Our Buying Process

We strive to make your selling process (and our buying process) as simple as possible. So we’ve boiled it all down to four phases: 


1- Submit a request for a quote on your ring

Provide information about the ring, such as the metal type, the diamond size and quality, and the ring's brand. Upload any certifications or appraisals you may have and add some photographs. The more information you supply the more accurate your quote will be. 


2- Receive a quote within 1 business day

We’ll email you a quote based on the information you provide. 


3- Ship your ring to us for an official valuation

We’ll evaluate the physical characteristics of your ring and give you an official offer. The shipping is secure and insured. 


4- Accept the offer and receive your payment

Once we’ve received and evaluated your ring, and agreed on an offer, we’ll mail you a check or process a bank transfer for a small fee. It’s really that easy. 


Benefits of working with us

Obviously White Pine isn’t the only online diamond jewelry buyer out there. You can find a ton of other online buyers with a simple Google search or two. 

But there are two main characteristics that make White Pine the clear-cut best option. Here’s what they are: 


Overall Process

The speed of our process compared to the competition is unmatched, especially since you're selling directly to us. Stack that on top of our competitive prices and the wide range of diamonds and rings we buy compared to competitors, and it’s a no-brainer.

At White Pine, you tell us some basic info about your diamond ring, we give you an estimate within one business day, and send payment immediately after accepting our offer.

We know your time is valuable, so we get right to it. While the other guys keep telling you to “hang tight.” 



There are other online buyers out there that will take you diamond engagement ring … and a bunch of other items.  In other words, they’re not fully focused on the diamond and jewelry industry. At White Pine, that’s all we do.  Remember all those diamond-specific services we mentioned earlier? We don’t just buy and sell diamonds. We also do diamond sorting, custom work, settings, special orders, we’ll even test if your diamonds are real or not. 

And which potential buyer do you think you’d get a fair, accurate offer from? The buyer that lives and breathes the diamond industry 24/7? Or the buyer that wants to also know if you have some Gucci sneakers you want to sell? 

We think it’s a pretty easy choice. But don’t just take our word for it. Check out our customer reviews and see why so many people prefer White Pine as their diamond buyer of choice. 

How to Prepare Your Engagement Ring for Sale

Once you’ve weighed your options and picked out the best place to sell your engagement ring, the next step is (usually) preparing your ring. 

If you’re selling to White Pine, you can skip this step entirely and save yourself the time and effort it’d take to prepare your engagement ring.

If you want to prepare it on your own, here are some tips: 


Cleaning the ring

Use a gentle jewelry cleaner or a solution of warm water and mild soap to clean the ring. Make sure to thoroughly clean all parts of the ring, including the band, prongs, and diamond.


Inspecting the ring

Look for any visible damage or wear and tear, such as scratches, chips, or bent prongs.


Polishing the ring

Use a soft cloth or a polishing cloth specifically designed for fine jewelry to buff the ring and remove any remaining dirt or tarnish.

You may also be asked to send a certificate of authenticity or appraisal for the diamond or jewelry if you have one, so keep that in mind. 

While the amount of time you’ll be required to clean and prepare your ring will vary, it’s often a step the seller wants to bypass.


That’s why, at White Pine, we don’t require you to prep or clean your ring before selling – all we need for the sale is the info about the ring and a certificate if you have one. 

If you don’t have or know the basic info, you can also send it to us and we’ll take a look to determine a quote. 


How Long Does it Take to Sell an Engagement Ring

You’ve done your research. You’ve found a buyer. Maybe even prepped and cleaned your ring. And agreed on a price. How much time has passed by?

The length of time it takes to sell an engagement ring can vary depending on a number of factors, including the condition of the ring, the market conditions, the price, and the what type of buyer or selling method you select.


If you’re selling the ring through a reputable online diamond buyer or a brick and mortar jewelry store, the process may take anywhere from a day to a week. 

At White Pine, we typically make an offer within 24 hours after receiving the engagement ring and send the payment immediately.

If you’re selling the ring through an auction or a consignment store, it may take longer (as in several weeks or even months), since the ring will need to be properly evaluated and marketed before it can be sold.

If you're selling on your own, on Ebay for example, it could take even longer as it depends on the people’s interest, negotiations, and the ring's price.

Overall, it's important to keep in mind that the process of selling an engagement ring can take some time, but by working with a reputable buyer or seller, and being prepared with all the necessary information and documentation, you can help to ensure a smooth and efficient sale.



Selling an engagement ring can sometimes be a difficult and emotional process, but with the right knowledge and guidance, it can be made much easier and it can feel great to move on.

Hopefully this article has provided you with lots of value and knowledge on how to safely and securely sell your engagement ring online, and get the best offer for it. 

To recap the process of how to sell your engagement ring: The first step is to understand the value of your engagement ring and determine a ballpark range of its worth.

Next, it's important to choose the right buyer to ensure a fair price and a secure transaction. Finally, you’ll prepare your ring for sale (if necessary) and negotiate the price with the buyer.

By following these steps, you can confidently navigate the process of selling your engagement ring and turn a difficult situation into an opportunity for financial gain.


And if you’re ready to sell now, White Pine is ready to receive your engagement ring and prepare an offer. 

Visit our engagement ring selling page, complete the form, and we’ll be in touch soon!