Which Jewelry Retailers Buy-Back And Offer Trade-In Programs In 2025?

 

When considering selling back jewelry, several prominent retailers offer buy-back and trade-in programs with specific terms and conditions. Here are details from some leading retailers:

(Quick note: Ready to sell your jewelry now? Visit our dedicated page, complete a simple form, and we'll respond within 24 hours.)

 

Kay Jewelers

 

KAY Jewelers Trade-In Policy Summary

 

Eligibility and Purchase Requirements:

 

• The purchase price of new jewelry must be at least double the trade-in value, excluding tax and shipping.

• Example: If original earrings were bought for $500, the new purchase must be at least $1,000.

• Store credit is not issued; new jewelry must be purchased during the upgrade.

 

Exclusions:

 

• No trade-in value for gemstones, gold, silver, or other metals.

• Diamonds that are chipped, cracked, damaged, or purchased as previously owned are ineligible.

• Trade-ins only apply for new diamond jewelry, not previously owned gemstone or metal jewelry.

 

Geographic and Procedural Restrictions:

 

• Trade-ins are accepted only from customers with addresses in North America or the United Kingdom.

• A 30-day retention period applies to returns associated with trade-ins, except in specific states (Alaska, Hawaii, Oklahoma, North Carolina, Delaware, and Florida).

• Trade-ins are processed in most KAY Jewelers stores and unavailable online.

 

Tiffany & Co.

 

Tiffany Jewelers Trade-In Policy Summary:

 

Tiffany & Co. does not offer a standard buyback program for its jewelry. However, they have an upgrade program specifically for engagement rings. Through this program, customers can trade in their Tiffany engagement ring for a new one, provided the new ring is at least twice the value of the original purchase. The trade-in value granted is based on the original purchase price of the ring. Typically, Tiffany & Co. does not buy back other types of jewelry items.

 

• High Resale Value: Tiffany jewelry retains its value well, often fetching a good % of the original purchase price.

• Assessment: Items should be appraised by a certified gemologist or a reputable buyer like White Pine to understand their market value.

• Original Packaging: Retaining the original Tiffany blue box and documentation can enhance the resale value.

 

Zales

 

Zales Trade-In & Upgrade Program Summary

 

Lifetime Diamond Trade-In Services

Zales offers a trade-in and upgrade program for diamond jewelry purchased from their stores. Customers can trade in their old diamond jewelry for new pieces, receiving the full value of the original purchase price. The new purchase must be at least double the original item's price.

 

Key Facts

 

• Only Zales diamond jewelry qualifies for trade-in.

• The upgrade purchase must be double the original purchase price or more.

• Color gemstone, pearl jewelry, and Previously Owned Treasures are not eligible.

• Trade-ins are done in-store and cannot be completed online.

 

Eligibility and Exclusions:

 

• This applies to diamond jewelry bought at Zales. The new piece must be at least twice the price of the original.

• Excludes pieces featuring only pearls, emeralds, sapphires, other gemstones, damaged diamonds, and Previously Owned Treasures.

 

Bring your Zales diamond jewelry to a local Zales store for consultation and evaluation.

 

REEDS Jewelers

 

REEDS Jewelers Diamond Trade-In Policy Summary

 

REEDS Jewelers allows customers to trade their diamond jewelry for a new diamond purchase if they present either the original diamond warranty or the original sales receipt.

 

Key Points:

 

• Eligibility: The original diamond jewelry must not be chipped, cracked, or damaged.

• Purchase Requirement: The net purchase price of the new diamond jewelry must be at least double the net purchase price of the trade-in item.

• Example: If the original diamond was purchased for $1000, the new diamond must be priced at $2000 or more, resulting in a net cost of $1000 after the trade-in (excluding taxes and fees).

• Exclusions: Taxes and other charges are not included in determining the trade-in value.

 

This policy ensures customers receive fair value for their original diamond jewelry while upgrading to a new piece.

 

James Allen

 

James Allen Lifetime Upgrade Policy Summary

 

Eligibility:

 

Loose natural diamonds and loose lab-grown diamonds purchased from James Allen are eligible.

 

Upgrade Requirements:

 

Natural Diamonds: You can exchange them for any replacement natural diamond of at least double the original value at 100% credit.

Lab-Grown Diamonds: Can be exchanged at 100% credit for any replacement lab-grown diamond of at least double the original value.

 

Conditions:

 

• The diamond being upgraded must be in its original condition.

• The original laboratory grading document must accompany the diamond.

 

General Tips for Selling Jewelry

 

1. Understand the Market Value: Before selling, appraise your jewelry by a certified gemologist or a serious buyer like White Pine to understand its market value.

2. Documentation: Keeping original receipts, certificates of authenticity, and original packaging can significantly increase the resale value.

3. Choose Reputable Buyers: Opt for well-known retailers or reputable auction houses to ensure a fair and transparent transaction process.

 

In summary, various retailers offer buy-back or trade-in options, each with specific terms. Evaluating these options based on your jewelry type and brand can help you get the best value when selling your items. Most want you to trade-in, so if you are looking for a quick cash offer, White Pine can help. You can sell engagement rings or sell diamond rings and other types of jewelry direct to us without having to list your item for sale.